Has anyone else noticed how overhyped bell kits are in beginner percussion programs? I get that they’re supposed to introduce young students to pitched percussion and basic music reading, but honestly, most of the bell kits I’ve seen handed out at school are flimsy and barely represent what students will actually play later (think mallet percussion like marimba or vibes). Plus, the sound is shrill at best, and it seems like it turns kids off from percussion entirely (I’ve seen more than a few give up after a year of just "dinging" away).
Is there something I’m missing here, or is this just a cost/convenience thing for school bands? Wouldn’t it make more sense to put the money toward a classroom xylophone, or even entry-level practice pads to focus on rhythm? Looking for thoughts-especially from band directors or teachers who have taught with (or without) bell kits. Is the bell kit actually essential, or is it just tradition holding us back?