I've been playing and collecting guitars long enough to see trends come and go, and I have to say the current reverence for the Gibson SG seems blown out of proportion. It's not that I don't appreciate the design or history, but when you look at modern build inconsistencies and the way everyone treats the SG like some untouchable relic of rock 'n' roll, you have to wonder: Are we ignoring better innovations in tone and craftsmanship? I've had a few SGs over the years, and while they have their quirks and undeniable legacy, the current market hype almost feels like a marketing construct rather than genuine appreciation for true quality.
What are your thoughts on modern SG models versus vintage ones? Is the reputation based more on nostalgia than on actual performance improvements, or am I missing something in the evolution of the design? And for those who still swear by the SG, how do you justify the high price tags when there are plenty of competitors offering more reliable construction and better value? I'm genuinely curious if it's just me being cynical or if others see through the status quo hype as well.